Skip to main content

Table 1 Efficacy of environmental, behavioral and non-pharmacological strategies on pain reactivity in newborn.

From: Non-pharmacological intervention for neonatal pain control

Behavioral, cognitive and contextual interventions

Level of evidence

Grade of Recommendation

 

Heel Prick

Venipuncture

Other

 

Non-nutritive sucking (NNS): placing a pacifier or non-lactating nipple in an infant’s mouth to promote sucking behavior with no breast or formula milk to provide nourishment.

1

1

-

Strong

Facilitated tucking: holding the arms and legs in a flexed position

1

1

3 ET Suctioning

Strong

Swaddling: wrapping securely the neonate in a sheet/blanket

1

1

-

Strong

Positioning: laying the neonate supine

3

3

-

Weak

Maternal touching and holding: cradling the baby in the mother’s arms

3

3

-

Weak

Environmental care: controlling/ reducing light and noise, clustering care etc.

3

3

-

Weak

Individualized developmental care e.g. limiting environmental stimuli, lateral positioning, using supportive bedding, monitoring behavioural clues, respecting circadian rhythms

-

-

3 ROP screening

Weak

Skin to skin or Kangaroo Mother Care an infants is placed on their care-giver’s bare chest during a painful procedure or for soothing after a painful procedure

1

2

2 IM

Strong

Sensorial saturation: multiple sensorial stimulation at gustatory, auditory, olfactory and tactile level

1

-

-

Strong

Music therapy: music with intrauterine sounds or instrumental music in association with NNS

3

3

-

Weak

Sucrose 24%: in dose of 0.1-0.3 ml orally 2 minutes before the procedure in preterm infants and 1-2 ml in term infants.

1

1

-

Strong

Breastfeeding or expressed human milk

1

1

-

Strong

Glucose solutions 20-30% in dose of 1-2ml orally 2 minutes before the procedure.

1

1

-

Strong

  1. ET suctioning= endotracheal suctioning, ROP= retinopathy of prematurity IM= intramuscular injection
  2. Legend
  3. 1. Sufficient evidence supports efficacy for reducing pain-related behaviors (support of two or more trials)
  4. 2. Limited evidence suggests efficacy for reducing pain-related behaviors (e.g. support of 1 trial or heterogeneity among trial)
  5. 3. Limited evidence suggests inefficacy for reducing pain-related behaviors (e.g. support of 1 trial or heterogeneity among trial)
  6. 4. Sufficient evidence supports inefficacy for reducing pain-related behaviors ( support of two or more trial)