| Zollino et al., | Rauch et al., | Zollino et al., | Van Buggenhout et al., | Rodrìguez et al., | Maas et al., | Izumi et al., | Okamoto et al., | Andersen et al., |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Am J Med Genet 2000 | Am J Med Genet 2001 | Am J Hum Genet 2003 | J Med Genet 2004 | Am J Med Genet 2005 | J Med Genet 2008 | Am J Med Genet 2010 | Am J Med Genet 2013 | Eur J Med Gen 2014 | |
 |  |  | 5 patients |  |  |  |  | 3 patients | |
Age at last observation (years) | Â | 5 | 1 | 5.6 to 13.3 | 4 | Â | 2.8 | 2 | 2 to 11 |
Genetic finding | 12 patients with > 5 Mb deletion and 3 patient s with < 5 Mb deletion | 191.5 kb deletion | 1.9 Mb deletion | > 2 Mb deletion | 1.9 Mb deletion | 8 patients with > 5 Mb deletion and 13 patients with ≤5 Mb deletion | 1.3 Mb deletion | 109 kb deletion | 60 to 377 kb deletion |
IUGR | 13/15 | – | + | 3/5 | + | 18/21 | + | + | 2/3 |
SGA | 13/15 | – | – | 3/5 | + | 15/20 | + | + | 2/3 |
Postnatal growth retardation | 15/15 | + | + | 5/5 | + | 16/21 | + | + | 1/3 |
Microcephaly | 14/15 | – | – | 2/5 | – | 19/20 | – | + | 0/3 |
Craniofacial | 15/15 | + | + | 5/5 | + | 20/21 | + | + | 3/3 |
High/broad forehead | N/A | + | + | 1/5 | – | 17/18 | – | + | 3/3 |
Frontal bossing | N/A | – | + | 0/5 | + | 0/21 | – |  | N/A |
Bitemporal narrowing | N/A | + | – | 0/5 | – | 0/21 | – | – | 2/3 |
Prominent glabella | N/A | + | + | 0/5 | – | 14/19 | – | + | 1/3 |
High arched eyebrows | N/A | + | – | 0/5 | – | 0/21 | – | + | 1/3 |
Hypertelorism | N/A | + | + | 0/5 | – | 16/19 | – | + | 3/3 |
Epicanthus | N/A | + | – | 0/5 | + | 7/17 | – | + | 2/3 |
Prominent eyes | N/A | + | + | 1/5 | – | 0/21 | – | + | 2/3 |
Downslanting palpebral fissures | N/A | – | – | 1/5 | – | 0/21 | + | + | 0/3 |
Abnormal ears | N/A | + | + | 1/5 | + | 17/20 | – | + | 2/3 |
Broad nasal bridge | N/A | + | – | 4/5 | + | 13/19 | + | + | 3/3 |
Short philtrum | N/A | + | – | 1/5 | + | 16/19 | + | + | 2/3 |
Downturned corners of the mouth | N/A | + | + | 0/5 | – | 14/19 | – | + | 0/3 |
Micrognathia | N/A | + | – | 0/5 | – | 15/20 | + | + | 3/3 |
Cleft lip/cleft palate | 6/15 | – | – | 1/5 | – | 3/19 | – | – | 0/3 |
Hypotonia | 15/15 | – | + | 0/5 | + | 13/19 | + | – | 2/3 |
Feeding difficulties | N/A | + | – | 1/5 | – | N/A | – | + | 3/3 |
Seizures | 14/15 | – | + | 2/5 | + | 15/21 | + | – | 0/3 |
Developmental delay | 15/15 | + | – | 5/5 | + | 21/21 | + | + | 3/3 |
Abnormal behaviour | N/A | ADHD | – | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | ADHD, aggressiveness | ADHD 1/3 |
CNS structural abnormalities | N/A | N/A | – | Sacral dimple 4/4; delayed myelinisation 1/1 | Sacral dimple | Sacral dimple 15/17 | N/A | – | Distal ventral chordae 1/1 |
Hearing loss | N/A | + | – |  | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |  |
Ophtalmological abnormalities | Iris coloboma 1/15 | – | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | 0/1 |
Cardiac features | 9/15 | – | – | N/A | – | ASD 2/19; AVSD 1/19; VSD 1/11; pulmonary stenosis 1/11 | N/A | – | Left aortic arch, retroesophageal subclavian artery 1/3 |
Urinary tract malformations | Renal hypoplasia 3/15; hydronephrosis 3/15; renal fusion 1/15; hypospadias 5/15 | – | – | Hypospadias 1/1; inguinal hernia 1/1 | Bilateral pyelectasia | Left kidney duplication 1/18; VUR 8/18; hypospadias 8/18; right cryptorchidism 1/18; clitoridomegaly 1/18; ventrally spaced anus 1/8 | N/A | – | VUR 1/3; left pyelectasia, cryptorchidism 1/3 |
Congenital diaphragmatic hernia | 0/15 | – | – | 1/5 | – | 0/21 | – | – | 0/3 |
Skeletal abnormalities | N/A | Clinodactyly of V fingers, cutaneous syndactyly of I and III toes | – | Hyperkyphosis 2/5; small hands and feet 1/1 | – | Scoliosis/hyperkyphosis 7/19; club feet 3/17 | Small nails | – | 0/3 |
 | Yang et al., | Lozier et al., | Callaway et al., | Derar et al., | Bernardini et al., | Boczek et al., | Barrie et al., | Jiang et al., | Hu et al., | Zanoni et al., |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chinese Medical Journal 2016 | Hum Genet 2018 | J Pediatr Genet 2018 | Genet in Med 2018 | Am J Med Genet 2018 | Am J Med Genet 2018 | Cold Spring Harb Mol Case Stud 2019 | BMC Med Genet 2019 | BMC Med Genom 2020 | Genet in Med 2021 | |
 |  |  | 2 patients | 3 patients |  | 3 patients |  |  |  | |
Age at last observation (years) | Â | 1.3 | Stillborn | 2.8 to 5 | 3 to 7.2 | 3 | 2.2 to 5 | 12 | 10.5 | Â |
Genetic finding | 10 patients with > 2 Mb deletion | Pathogenic SNV | 19 Mb deletion | Pathogenic SNV | 68 to 166 kb deletion | Pathogenic SNV | Pathogenic SNV | Pathogenic SNV | Pathogenic SNV | 18 patients with pathogenic SNV |
IUGR | 5/10 | – | + | 2/2 | 2/3 | + | 3/3 | + | + | 7/17 |
SGA | 5/10 | – | N/A | N/A | 3/3 | + | 2/2 | + | + | 1/18 |
Postnatal growth retardation | 10/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 3/3 | + | 2/3 | + | + | 16/17 |
Microcephaly | 0/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 0/3 | + | 2/3 | – | + | 1/18 |
Craniofacial | 10/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 3/3 | + | 3/3 | + | + | 17/17 |
High/broad forehead | 10/10 | + | N/A | 0/2 | 3/3 | – | 1/3 | – | – | 8/17 |
Frontal bossing | 0/10 | – | N/A | 0/2 | N/A | – | 0/3 | – | – | 2/17 |
Bitemporal narrowing | 0/10 | – | N/A | 0/2 | 2/3 | – | 0/3 | – | – | 0/18 |
Prominent glabella | 10/10 | – | N/A | 0/2 | 0/3 | – | 0/3 | + | – | 0/18 |
High arched eyebrows | 10/10 | – | N/A | 1/2 | 3/3 | + | 0/3 | + | + | 2/17 |
Hypertelorism | 10/10 | + | N/A | 1/2 | 2/3 | + | 0/3 | + | + | 6/17 |
Epicanthus | 0/10 | + | N/A | 0/2 | 3/3 | – | 0/3 | + | + | 2/17 |
Prominent eyes | 9/10 | – | N/A | 0/2 | 3/3 | – | 0/3 | – | – | 0/18 |
Downslanting palpebral fissures | 0/10 | – | N/A | 0/2 | 0/3 | – | 0/3 | – | – | 0/18 |
Abnormal ears | 2/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 2/3 | + | 1/3 | – | + | 8/17 |
Broad nasal bridge | 10/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 2/3 | + | 1/3 | + | – | 4/17 |
Short philtrum | 9/10 | – | N/A | 2/2 | 2/3 | – | 0/3 | + | – | 2/17 |
Downturned corners of the mouth | 5/10 | – | N/A | 2/2 | 2/3 | – | 0/3 | + | – | 0/18 |
Micrognathia | 4/10 | – | N/A | 2/2 | 1/3 | – | 0/3 | + | + | 3/17 |
Cleft lip/cleft palate | 2/0 | – | + | 0/2 | 1/3 | – | 0/3 | – | – | 0/18 |
Hypotonia | 9/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 2/3 | + | 3/3 | + | – | 12/17 |
Feeding difficulties | 3/10 | – | N/A | 2/2 | 1/3 | – | 0/3 | + | – | 9/18 |
Seizures | 8/10 | – | N/A | 0/2 | 0/3 | – | 0/3 | – | – | 2/17 |
Developmental delay | 10/10 | + | N/A | 2/2 | 3/3 | + | 3/3 | + | + | 13/17 |
Abnormal behaviour | N/A | N/A | N/A | 0/2 | ADHD 1/3 | Anxiety, hyperactivity, aggressiveness | Autism 1/1 | N/A | N/A | Autism 7/17; ADHD 6/17; Aggressiveness 2/17; Anxiety 2/17 |
CNS structural abnormalities | N/A | N/A | N/A | 0/2 | Subependymal and intarathalamic hyperechogenic spots 1/3 | Sacral dimple | Isolated 4 mm subependymal gray matter heterotopia 1/2 | – | N/A | T2 hyperintensity and volume loss of the periatrial white matter 1/10; 8 mm pineal cyst, non-specific mild diffuse T2/FLAIR signal hyperintensity in the bilateral parietal and occipital white matter, small thoracic spinal cord syrinx 1/10; few small areas of gliosis in the frontal and periatrial area 1/10; thin corpus callosum, white matter lesions 1/10 |
Hearing loss | N/A | N/A | N/A | Â | Â | N/A | Â | N/A | N/A | 0/16 |
Ophtalmological abnormalities | N/A | N/A | N/A | 0/2 | Myopia 1/1 | N/A | Myopia 1/1 | N/A | N/A | Refraction defects 4/18; strabismus 2/18; bilateral keratoconus, retinitis pigmentosa, optic atrophy, corneal transplant 1/18 |
Cardiac features | ASD 3/8; pulmonary stenosis 2/8 | N/A | N/A | 0/2 | Partial AVCD 1/2; mitral valve prolapse 1/2 | N/A | N/A | – | – | Mild pulmonary artery stenosis 1/18; small PFO 1/18; interrupted aortic arch, VSD 1/18 |
Urinary tract malformations | 1/10 | Rotation of right kidney | N/A | 0/2 | 0/3 | N/A | Bilateral renal hypoplasia, CKD 1/2 | – | N/A | Left renal agenesis 1/18; left hydronephrosis and hypospadias 1/18; bilateral cryptorchidism 1/18; congenital bilateral inguinal hernia 1/18 |
Congenital diaphragmatic hernia | 0/10 | – | + | 0/2 | 0/3 | – | 0/3 | – | – | 0/18 |
Skeletal abnormalities | 1/10 | Clinodactyly of V fingers | N/A | 0/2 | Mild scoliosis, bilateral pes cavus, syndaktyly II-III toes 1/3 | – | 0/3 | Clinodactyly of V fingers | – | 8/18 (pectus excavatum, scapulae alatae, mild scoliosis, prominent knees, flat feet, broad forefeet, bilateral clinodactyly of the V toe 1/18; 11 ossified ribs and 6 non rib-bearing lumbar vertebrae 1/18; severe arthrosis of wrist and knee 1/18; clinodactyly of V fingers 3/18; bilateral cutaneous incomplete syndactyly of II and III toes 2/18; pes planus 2/18) |