Skip to main content

Table 1 Pros and cons of screening for type 1 diabetes

From: Autoantibody test for type 1 diabetes in children: are there reasons to implement a screening program in the general population? A statement endorsed by the Italian Society for Paediatric Endocrinology and Diabetes (SIEDP-ISPED) and the Italian Society of Paediatrics (SIP)

Pros

Cons

Possible prevention of DKA at onset of diabetes

Potential increased anxiety in parents/carers

Opportunity for time to adjust to diagnosis

High numbers of individuals genetically at risk, but who don’t develop T1D

Genetic testing for high-risk genes/genetic risk scores possible at birth for use in combination with autoantibodies

If using IAb alone:

- Likely need testing more than once

- Will miss those diagnosed before screening

and those who seroconvert after screening

IAb detectable with fingerprick test, easy to administer, sensitive and specific

Treatment of early hyperglycaemia can be challenging

May be intervention studies to delay development or prevent T1D

Cost/effectveness still a matter of debate

New drug (teplizumab) available to delay the onset of T1D in high-risk individuals

No drug licensed to definitively prevent diabetes

  1. Modified from Besser R.E.J. et al., Arch Dis Chil 2022